Hi Michael,
In your show you mentioned a record that got "recalled" due to stupidly horrible sound. It's awesome when they listen to customers.
I have an example of one I probably should have returned, The Shouting Matches "Grownass Man." The music is pretty cool, nothing earth-shattering but fun bluesy rock. But the production value was so LOW, in an "indie, low-fi, shoe gaze" way that it seriously detracts from the performance. It's as if they went for a certain aesthetic that truly hurt them, and I can't reconcile that beyond concluding they just don't give a shit about their music or us. It's a bad place to be for both of us.
It's a shame because the pressing was really nice and quiet. I downloaded the MP3 version from the included card. It sounds almost the same, possibly better-balanced actually. When I look at the price difference between the MP3 release and the LP I'm not happy.