$700-800 list price. And by the way, can you identify what the music is? You forgot to do that...
How Much Would You Pay For This Cartridge?
- Log in or register to post comments
![](/sites/all/themes/hometech/images/headicon.png)
![MalachiLui's picture MalachiLui's picture](/images/user_account_pictures/picture-109399-1589425560.jpg)
![lecorbu's picture lecorbu's picture](https://www.stereophile.com/images/default_user_85x85.jpg)
Strange how similar Allison Krauss’s....”The lucky One” sounds in melody and chord structure to an unrecorded master: (Blaze Foley...Clay Pigeons)
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=KB_2CUj3y6Y
Cart maybe Hana E series MC? $475
![Lazer's picture Lazer's picture](/images/user_account_pictures/picture-71987-1464660601.jpg)
Like its in the same price range as a 2m black. But I’m guessing it costs less.
![Nightfly3000's picture Nightfly3000's picture](https://www.stereophile.com/images/default_user_85x85.jpg)
There's no sparkle in this pass so unless there is something "wrong" with this clip I would not be purchasing this cartridge.
![Jim Tavegia's picture Jim Tavegia's picture](/images/user_account_pictures/picture-49337-1399229075.jpg)
my rig here are the house, so I'm guessing about $200. I'm probably way off, but I've been told that many times before.
![Jim Tavegia's picture Jim Tavegia's picture](/images/user_account_pictures/picture-49337-1399229075.jpg)
I have this album so I know it pretty well.
![cdvinyl's picture cdvinyl's picture](https://www.stereophile.com/images/default_user_85x85.jpg)
From that sample size it sounds to be in the $600-$750.00 range.
![ao's picture ao's picture](https://www.stereophile.com/images/default_user_85x85.jpg)
![Chemguy's picture Chemguy's picture](/images/user_account_pictures/picture-84083-1564454453.jpg)
I’m not sure. Was it the only thing playing the record?
;-)
![Anton D's picture Anton D's picture](/images/user_account_pictures/picture-82231-1586794921.jpg)
65 dollars, MM, variant of a Rega Carbon?
![mtemur's picture mtemur's picture](https://www.stereophile.com/images/default_user_85x85.jpg)
![Anton D's picture Anton D's picture](/images/user_account_pictures/picture-82231-1586794921.jpg)
I will cheat and add Sumiko Amethyst to the guesses, but you get the Sumiko credit!
![Anton D's picture Anton D's picture](/images/user_account_pictures/picture-82231-1586794921.jpg)
The price point seems right for your guess!
![JohnnyCanuck's picture JohnnyCanuck's picture](https://www.stereophile.com/images/default_user_85x85.jpg)
![gMRfk6LMHn's picture gMRfk6LMHn's picture](/images/user_account_pictures/picture-52067-1452615166.jpg)
Considering that I am listening to this file on my PC, I would say around $300. When the track started I really liked the sound of the acoustic guitar(s) and the bass was nicely defined, but as soon as I heard the voice I thought it was pinched and restricted.
![JohnnyRasheed's picture JohnnyRasheed's picture](https://www.stereophile.com/images/default_user_85x85.jpg)
I like this sound. It's warmer, or darker, than the iTunes version, however the iTunes version though bringing out the sparkle/top-end exacerbates the compression and sibilance in her voice.
If you want to emulate the iTunes version then clearly this combination of cartridge and phono stage isn't for you.
I would be surprised if this cartridge is a high-end (for me high end would be eg a Quintet black) but otherwise haven't got a clue how much it might cost!
At the same time I am intrigued as to how much warmer this version is, and perhaps a Trichord Diablo phono stage would be a better match for this cartridge to bring out top-end sparkle.
((Am assuming digital conversion faithful))
my humble two-penneth :-)
JR
![Tom L's picture Tom L's picture](https://www.stereophile.com/images/default_user_85x85.jpg)
Sounds OK, but...for a cartridge I can't see, I would pay exactly ZERO dollars.
![abelb1's picture abelb1's picture](https://www.stereophile.com/images/default_user_85x85.jpg)
I'm not familiar with this album but I thought this presentation sounded well balanced with no obvious flaws. If I spent under $150 on this I'd be happy with my purchase.
![Lemon Curry's picture Lemon Curry's picture](https://www.stereophile.com/images/default_user_85x85.jpg)
It's an under $500 cart, perhaps even less
![atomlow's picture atomlow's picture](/images/user_account_pictures/picture-48275-1399229075.jpg)
I'll stick with my Shure m97 with JICO SAS needle. For something that needs to be replaced every 1000 hrs I can't imagine, I'll ever want anything more than the JICO. At times, it does have sibilance problems but generally delivers magical sound. I recently tried the Denon DL-110 MC and at first, I really liked it but it became too boomy for me at higher volumes. Changing back to the JICO made everything right.
My guess is the hidden needle/cartridge is $39.
I'll leave cartridges $500-$20,000 for anyone who has the money to replace every 1000hrs. I already spend too much on records :)
![GruvyWade's picture GruvyWade's picture](/images/user_account_pictures/picture-98062-1519577110.png)
The tonality is rich and warm, and the reproduction of the guitar is gorgeous, with excellent midrange detail. The bass isn't as well defined as the mid-range, but its still quite nice. The vocals seem a bit recessed- but that could be the recording. Sometimes there is a flaw with the "s" sound on her vocals, which probably limits the price to under $250. If you invited friends over to listen, though, they be spellbound.
![alucas's picture alucas's picture](/images/user_account_pictures/picture-98609-1484529941.jpg)
![AnalogJ's picture AnalogJ's picture](https://www.stereophile.com/images/default_user_85x85.jpg)
It's nice, smooth, but none of the instruments or her voice are particularly juicy or fleshed out harmonically. The sound is nicely balanced, but not something I would spend a lot on. I would have guessed not more than a couple hundred.
![Ivan Lietaert's picture Ivan Lietaert's picture](/images/user_account_pictures/picture-109514-1550057693.jpg)
There's a nasty, wormhole dark matter whatever, twist in this question. Why would I even consider buying this cartridge if I can judge its quality by listening to a digital recording, played back on lousy laptop speakers?
At one point, her 's' hurts a bit, but is that due to the needle? The recording? The digital file?
It could be valued between $1 and $20,000
![Jeroen's picture Jeroen's picture](/images/user_account_pictures/picture-110056-1555879796.jpg)
I wouldn't pay anything for it since I have too many cartridges already. ;-) I know I'm late to the party (just registered for the first time) but I didn't look and I'm going on what I heard.
I would guess it's a basic well designed mass produced cart with a bonded elliptical stylus on a very good 'table.
Since I already have an At95e modified with a wood body and HE stylus, I'm not tempted. I also have an AT91 carbon that sells for the same price as 4 bags of peanuts (literally) and sounds awesome.
This sounds ok, clean some dynamics, not much spatial clues. A bit 'mèh'. But I'm spoiled. :-P
![shawnwes's picture shawnwes's picture](https://www.stereophile.com/images/default_user_85x85.jpg)
What's the cartridge we were listening to? Inquiring minds want to know...
![Boomer's picture Boomer's picture](https://www.stereophile.com/images/default_user_85x85.jpg)
Well, it's been over a year and a half since Mr. Fremer wrote the article so how about spilling the beans on how much the cartridge cost?
![dial's picture dial's picture](https://www.stereophile.com/images/default_user_85x85.jpg)